Medicare Aduhelm Coverage Policy Overrules FDA: Can Two Wrongs Make A Right?

Plenty of people believe the US FDA should never have approved Biogen/Eisai’s Alzheimer’s therapy. But does that really mean it is okay for the Medicare agency to decide as a matter of policy that the drug has not been proven safe and effective?

Alzheimer's disease on MRI
The draft NCD from CMS had a very different reading of the data than FDA. • Source: Shutterstock

The Washington Post’s January 12 front-pageheadline on the US Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ proposed policy on the beta amyloid antibody Audhelm was, to put it mildly, misleading: “Medicare plans to cover pricey Alzheimer’s drug.”

In fact (as the article itself makes very clear), Medicare is doing nothing of the kind: the Biogen, Inc./Eisai Co., Ltd. Alzheimer’s treatment will be “covered” only in the context of randomized, controlled trials intended to establish safety and efficacy. In other words, the Medicare program is essentially returning aducanumab to investigational status – the June 2021 approval by the Food & Drug Administration notwithstanding

More from Medicare

Will International Prices Influence Medicare Price Negotiation?

 
• By 

A former CMS official suggested the most likely way it could happen is through a Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation demonstration.

Industry Leaders Grapple With Trump’s Most Favored Nation Pricing Plan

 

At the Bank of America health care conference, pharma leaders speculated on the impact of Trump’s most favored nation pricing executive order on US and European markets.

New Guidance Suggests SubQ Keytruda, Opdivo Formulations May Not Avoid Medicare Negotiations

 

New draft guidance on the third cycle of Medicare drug price negotiations goes against Merck and BMS expectations for their cancer drugs. The guidance also tackles Part B and renegotiated prices for the first time.

House Budget Bill Includes Delayed Orphan Fix, Also Risks Downstream Cell and Gene Coverage

 

The first two classes of negotiated drugs under the Inflation Reduction Act would not benefit from a rare disease adjustment House Republicans included in their reconciliation package.

More from Government Payers

New Guidance Suggests SubQ Keytruda, Opdivo Formulations May Not Avoid Medicare Negotiations

 

New draft guidance on the third cycle of Medicare drug price negotiations goes against Merck and BMS expectations for their cancer drugs. The guidance also tackles Part B and renegotiated prices for the first time.

House Budget Bill Includes Delayed Orphan Fix, Also Risks Downstream Cell and Gene Coverage

 

The first two classes of negotiated drugs under the Inflation Reduction Act would not benefit from a rare disease adjustment House Republicans included in their reconciliation package.

Trump’s Rx Pricing Order: The Best-Case And Worst-Case Scenarios

 

US trade and tariff leverage might successfully push European and other countries to pay more for medicines, but if not, President Trump’s executive order includes potential US drug withdrawal and other options to entice industry to lower US prices.